I have first hand knowledge from this last week. Antelope hunting in Wyoming, I tried the rage hypo for the first time. I too have heard good and bad about rage, and was curious. I have always shot muzzy or slick trick, 100 grain.
I shot the hypo at antelope from 46 yards with 65 lb bow...either animal moved, or wind caused drift, but I hit square in the shoulder. Did not get full penetration or pass thru. The antelope ran 60 yards, piled up, got up and tried to run, could not. Shoulder blade busted in half. The arrow only went in 6"-8", but did significant damage. I watched animal bleed out and die in about 15 minutes. Arrow still stuck in shoulder. Massive entry wound, great blood trail. Yes is very loud impact, sounded like I hit a garage door with a ball bat. I will not throw away my muzzys but I will shoot the rage hypos this deer season. They fly exactly like my field points.