The buck in the top picture is still alive and much bigger. I haven't been able to catch him on camera but I have seen him in the past two weeks in a field.
The big buck in the bottom pictures was shot during the 2005 Juvenile Hunt by a 16 year old and never recovered. He was trailed for about 2.5 miles and no one has seen him again. I assume he died since he hasn't been seen or has not shown up on any more trail cam photos