1 Adult, 2 Kids missing

Chattanooga Fishing Forum

Help Support Chattanooga Fishing Forum:

Fishin Fool

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 2, 2006
Messages
3,310
Location
Chattanooga
http://www.chattanoogan.com/2013/1/16/242382/Adult-2-Children-Missing-After-Boat.aspx</p>

</p>

There may be a lot more to this story than they are reporting, but I can't imagine taking 4 kids, 2 adults, out on a canoe in a raging, flooding creek or river. I suppose they may have been fleeing flood waters, but the story doesn't indicate that. Several sources say it was simply a trip, without life jackets. Sad, my prayers are with them.
</p>
 
I cant imagine anyone being this foolish to have that many people in a canoe, in a raging flood, for fun? Something is seriously wrong with this picture.
 
I have been watching that and very concerned for the Families.. At what Point should an adult (Two Adults) looking at a raging flood consider that to place four children in a small boat and to launch themselves into a most certain disaster stop to consider it to be a dumb idea?
 
I agree Spur. If they were out for fun, and in a canoe, in raging flood waters, without life jackets, then I can't imagine what the adults were thinking. Again, maybe they were fleeing flood waters. Reports say they were Amish so maybe they had no way to contact rescue but I find that hard to believe.
 
i hate that this happened to the kids but how stupid do you got to be. these people dont deserve to have kids if they are taking them out in this. everytime we have bad weather you hear about some moron out in the water, just trying to catch a fish. sorry but there aint a fish out there worth dying over. what i hate is that somebody has to risk their life trying to rescue them. if they are that stupid to be out there then let them die. and if the adult lives then charge them with attempted murder or reckless endangerment. if they start seeing that their stupidity has conciquences then maybe people will start thinking before they do stupid stuff
 
If it was in fact a situation where they were not able to get to the store or whatever. Then send An adult and leave the children high and dry where they are. Even without Power, Water or food it would be better to sit it out than to risk death. From what I am seeing, it was not about flooded roads. These people went to a small flooded river for a Boat-ride.
 
Regardless of the reason for them being in a boat in that condition, there are families that are in pain for the loss they have suffered. I for one am hoping for the best for those who survived and the families of the victims.
 
I am sorry, but to take your kids with you, IF it was a thrill ride, I have no sympathy for stupidity. I heard a small flat bottom, no life jackets. Yes I feel sorry for the family that will have to bury their kin.....but, like the two that drowned a few years back below the dam in this same condition............what the HELL are they thinking????
 
What I am watching is this awful weather conditions turning into freezing rain and snow with drastically colder temps. If those people are out there clinging onto trees and brush. How long could they make it in these much colder conditions.
 
I don't think they are in rescue mode anymore. It is now recovery mode from what the Cleveland Banner and the Times Free Press are reporting. Free Press is also saying the search has been called off until tomorrow. Water would be very cold right now and I doubt that anyone could have stood it for more than an hour, especially in high current. It's a very sad thing. From what I have read today the children were all very young, and apparently the pregnant wife and her husband decided for whatever reason to get into a canoe (!) and take the children with them. The two children that are missing are 6 and 8. The Banner says because of their religion, that details are hard to come by. I don't see what religion has to do with details about a tragedy. </p>

</p>

http://www.clevelandbanner.com/view/full_story/21439414/article-Three-missing-after-canoe-tips-in-Polk-County?instance=latest_articles</p>
 
Yes, I'm seeing more that it was a canoe. Sending prayers up...for a tragic, yet sensless death of this family. If it was a Amish faimily, I find it strange, they have always seemed to have their act together...dealing with them over the years.
 
Quick update on this subject. According to interviews, the parents were simply out on the flooded creek to have a good time. Not fleeing flood waters, just joy riding. I'd like to get some reactions and just see how folks feel about this one. To me, this is like two adults getting drunk, and taking off to the store with 4 kids in the car, wrecking and killing some of the kids. Am I wrong here? I mean, I certainly think it's a huge tragedy, and I know the mother is hurting beyond belief, but is there not a point where a finger is pointed and someone say "you were wrong for putting your children at risk and as a adult you should have known better" The chief of police up there said it was just " a strange accident that sometimes happens". I just wonder if the parents had left the kids locked in a car in the summer and they had died of heat stroke if he'd have felt the same way? I just don't get this one......I don't understand the thinking, or lack there of. I don't care if they are Amish, Baptist, Catholic, Jewish or Muslim. Usually Amish people are pretty level headed, and I don't buy the excuse that their religion had anything to do with their decision making. Is it just me or does anyone else see this as a criminal act right up there with driving while drunk, handing a kid a loaded gun to play with, or giving a 3 year old matches to play with in a barn?

I've been out on swift water before, in a large boat, and we all know how quickly things can go bad. Two people in a canoe would have been an unreal risk in the flood, but now add 4 kids in that canoe! I'd be wary of getting in a pontoon boat with those type waters. My prayers are certainly with these folks, and I hope God grants them comfort, but for the life of me I don't see how someone walks away from this without a serious look at their parenting suitability at the very least.
 
I absolutely agree with FF. Do not pass this off as strange accident. Meatheads need to view things like this with a harsh warning so they will at least try to not repeat what they may see as something to not try.
 
Here's a picture I took a few years ago, You just can't fix stupid. At least the kids have PFDs.
 

Attachments

  • overloaded boat.jpg
    overloaded boat.jpg
    61.3 KB
I remember that pic Bomber. Wasn't that on a holiday out by the Nuclear plant? Just goes to show how dangerous a boat, let alone a canoe, that is over loaded can be. Those aren't even fast moving flood waters either!
</p>

</p>

</p>

</p>

MadBomber - 1/20/2013 8:25 AM Here's a picture I took a few years ago, You just can't fix stupid. At least the kids have PFDs.
</p>
 
My take whether you believe it or not. I live about 5 mi from their settlement. These are a very simple and very religious people. They are sheltered from society as we know it. This is part of their religion also. They have a building on site where they sell their Vegetables and other wears. Their everyday life is working with their hands. I have seen first hand how they also have time for fun or play. The Conasauga creek running out of the mountains circles their property. These people I'm sure if you ask them about boating safety or protective devices wouldn't have a clue of what your talking about. With that said I could very easy see them just having fun in a canoe or some other craft in a field near the creek and being sucked into the raging torrent before they could do anything. I hope Gods hand will be with them during their time of grief. If you ever get a chance come to the Delano community next summer and drive thru their settlement where you will see the hands of time go backward. Tenncrappie
 
Back
Top