First off, thanks for all of the suggestions. There's a few of them that we'll be trying in the near future.
After going over the options with the boss, she decided to go to Birmingham to the Fishmarket Restaraunt, a place downtown that has KILLER seafood. With my work schedule I wanted to stay a little closer to home, but I've always let her have the say when it comes to anniversaries. We had a good time, got away from everything for a while, and enjoyed a great meal.