I was the 3rd person who joined CFF (in April 2005). I followed the creator, DHaun, and his daughter. I wrote a newspaper article about it, helping it get off the ground. From there, I watched it grow into a "Village" - people who helped people. Annual picnics and other in-person gatherings were the norm. No telling how many lifetime fishing partnerships were formed. We even held litter cleanups (see 2010 photo below).
At that time, Internet Discussion Boards, especially those that were somewhat localized, were unusual. I met so many people who remain good friends today, some who have sadly passed on. It was awesome to watch CFF grow into a strong community.
It didn't matter what you fished for, everybody shared.
IMHO, the decline began when more and more web-based outlets were created (including social media) that catered more specifically to each individual's interests. I might have helped the decline when I created the
"Chattanooga Fishing Forum" Facebook Page (private Page with app. 6,000 Members currently). I called it our "parallel universe."
But slowly it seems bass anglers went to bass forums, crappie guys went to crappie forums and the same with catfish folks, etc.
As original core members slowly but surely dropped out, and the numbers of CFF'ers continued to grow, it lost it's "Comraderie Factor." I know at one time there were more than 11,000. Now, after new owners changed some stuff on CFF, I don't know how many registered users there are.
Internet Forums can't be guided or control by any one person or even a group of persons. They become the "collective" personality of every single user combined. After nearly 20 years in existence, the collective personality "one big, happy family" atmosphere is definitely gone. It still has a place on the "Minnownet," but it's a very small place.
Apparently just enough for the current owners to justify the expense based upon the numbers of Ads it serves. Maybe someday the personality will change again.If so, I hope I live to see it.